In civil proceedings, there is an increasing trend towards seeking solutions that enable disputes to be resolved quickly, at lower cost and to the satisfaction of all parties. One of the available tools for achieving this desired outcome is mediation – a procedure provided for in the Code of Civil Procedure, which allows a settlement to be reached in confidence, with the support of an impartial mediator.
Contrary to popular belief, mediation is not merely an ‘additional option’, but a fully-fledged dispute resolution procedure capable of yielding tangible procedural and financial benefits. In particular – in accordance with the Act on Court Costs in Civil Cases – reaching a settlement through mediation may result in a refund of up to 100% of the court fees paid.
Characteristics of court-referred mediation
Mediation may be conducted on the basis of an agreement between the parties or a court referral – both before proceedings are initiated and at any stage thereof. Mediation is voluntary, confidential, and its proceedings are not recorded in the case file.
At its core, court-based mediation is characterised by voluntariness, confidentiality, impartiality and flexibility. The voluntary aspect of court-based mediation is based on the fact that the parties must unanimously express their willingness to undertake the mediation process and also accept the mediator. Furthermore, even after such a decision has been made, they may change their position if they see no possibility of an out-of-court resolution of the conflict and may withdraw from the mediation process.
Stages of mediation – from initiation to settlement
The mediation procedure follows a set pattern:
- Initiation – as mentioned earlier, mediation may be initiated in two ways: at the initiative of the parties to the dispute themselves – through a joint application or agreement – or by order of the court. In the latter case, the court formally refers the parties to mediation, though participation remains voluntary. Such a referral is an invitation to talks rather than an order – the parties may accept or decline it. Even at this stage, it is important to determine whether the parties genuinely see room for compromise.
- Mediation agreement – once a mediator has been selected and their appointment accepted by both parties, the rules of procedure are established. The mediator sets out the basic principles – in particular, the guarantee of confidentiality, the requirement for impartiality and neutrality towards both parties – and describes how the meetings will proceed. Costs are also discussed – the mediator’s fee, any additional charges, and how these will be settled between the parties. The aim of this stage is to establish a procedural framework that is acceptable to all participants.
- Mediation sessions – mediation meetings may take the form of joint sessions – with both parties present at the same time – or ‘caucuses’, i.e. individual discussions between the mediator and each party. The latter model is sometimes used in situations of high emotional tension or where the issues at hand are particularly sensitive. The mediator’s role is not only to facilitate the discussion, but above all to support the process of seeking solutions that are realistic and satisfactory for all participants.
- Settlement – if the parties reach an agreement, it is recorded in the form of a settlement agreement. This document should precisely set out the terms of the agreement, as well as the manner and deadlines for their implementation. At the request of the parties, the mediator submits the settlement agreement to the court for approval. Once a declaration of enforceability has been granted, the settlement becomes an enforceable title, meaning it can be enforced in the manner applicable to court judgments. It is worth noting that in civil proceedings, an approved mediation settlement has the same legal force as a court judgment.
Mediation costs and their settlement
The costs of mediation in civil cases are regulated by the provisions of the Regulation of the Minister of Justice on the remuneration and expenses of mediators. The rates vary depending on the nature of the case:
- in non-property matters – the fee is PLN 150 for the first mediation session and PLN 100 for each subsequent session,
- in property matters – the fee is 1% of the value of the subject matter of the dispute, but not less than PLN 150 and not more than PLN 2,000 for the entire mediation process.
Additional expenses related to the organisation of the mediation process may be added to these amounts, such as the cost of hiring a room or the mediator’s travel expenses if the sessions take place outside their office.
As a general rule, the costs of mediation are shared equally between the parties, unless they agree on a different method of bearing them – e.g. in a proportion corresponding to the degree of concessions made or contribution to the dispute.
Benefits of mediation
Mediation, as an alternative means of dispute resolution, offers a number of significant advantages, which make it an increasingly popular choice among parties to civil proceedings.
- Speeding up proceedings – unlike traditional court proceedings, which can last many months and often even years, mediation allows an agreement to be reached quickly – often within a few weeks. Avoiding the need for a lengthy exchange of pleadings, waiting for court dates and conducting extensive evidential proceedings significantly shortens the time taken to resolve the dispute.
- Reduced costs – mediation involves a significant reduction in expenses, both in terms of court fees and legal representation costs. Under the Act on Court Costs in Civil Cases, if a settlement is reached before the first hearing begins, it is possible to recover up to 100% of the claim fee paid. The costs of legal fees are also lower compared to a lengthy trial, which directly translates into savings for both parties.
- Confidentiality – the principle of full confidentiality applies during mediation. This means that information disclosed during mediation sessions cannot be used in further court proceedings unless it is covered by the settlement. This allows the parties to openly present their arguments and proposed solutions without fear of subsequent legal consequences. This is particularly important in disputes involving sensitive information, trade secrets or personal data.
- Flexibility of solutions – mediation allows for the development of agreements tailored to the individual needs of the parties. The settlement may include solutions going beyond the standard scope of a court ruling – e.g. establishing a detailed payment schedule, additional benefits in kind, or even forward-looking measures such as continued business cooperation. This makes it possible to reach a compromise that not only resolves the dispute but also helps to maintain business or personal relationships.
Limitations and risks
Mediation, whilst effective, is not a one-size-fits-all solution. Its success depends on the parties’ willingness to cooperate and their readiness to compromise. In cases of deep-seated conflict or bad faith, the mediation process may end without an agreement, thereby prolonging the entire proceedings.
Nevertheless, mediation is undoubtedly an extremely beneficial form of conflict resolution in many respects. The outcomes of the mediation process will certainly be the most satisfactory, as the parties take an active part in seeking a resolution to the conflict. If, on the other hand, you are interested in mediation proceedings, court-ordered mediation or similar matters, please make use of the services of HWW Hewelt Wojnowski Lindner i Wspólnicy.
Frequently asked questions
Is mediation mandatory in civil cases?
Mediation is a voluntary procedure, which means that the parties must unanimously express their will to undertake it and accept the mediator. Even if the court refers the parties to mediation, participation in it remains voluntary and each party may withdraw from the process if they do not see the possibility of resolving the conflict out of court.
How much does mediation cost in property matters?
In property matters, the mediation fee is one percent of the value of the subject matter of the dispute, but not less than one hundred and fifty zloty and not more than two thousand zloty for the entire proceedings. Additional expenses may be added to these amounts, such as the costs of renting a room or the mediator’s travel expenses, if the sessions take place outside their seat.
Does a mediation settlement have the force of a court judgment?
Yes, after approval by the court and granting an enforcement clause, a mediation settlement becomes an enforcement title. This means that it has the same legal force as a court judgment and can be enforced under the procedure appropriate for court decisions, which allows for effective enforcement of the arrangements contained in the document.
Can information from mediation be used in court?
During mediation, the principle of full confidentiality applies, which means that information disclosed during sessions cannot be used in further court proceedings. The exception is only those elements that will be covered by the concluded settlement, thanks to which the parties can freely discuss solutions without fear of negative procedural consequences.
Can I obtain a refund of the court fee after mediation?
Concluding a settlement as a result of mediation may result in a refund of even one hundred percent of the paid court fee, in accordance with the Act on Court Costs in Civil Cases. This is one of the significant financial benefits arising from this method of dispute resolution, which allows avoiding lengthy and costly court proceedings.
Running a company with a matter to resolve?
That is where most conversations with a lawyer begin. A consultation is paid, PLN 600 net. You pay for a real opinion: whether you have a legal problem, what you can do about it and roughly what it costs. It ties you to nothing further, and you do not need to know the law, that part is on us.
- 1 Talk
You tell us what is going on, in your own words.
- 2 What next
We tell you your options and what it costs.
- 3 We act
You give the go-ahead and the matter is ours.
HWW Hewelt Wojnowski Lindner i Wspólnicy is a Warsaw law firm advising businesses and public entities. We combine experience in commercial law, energy, tax, data protection and litigation to deliver solutions tailored to our clients’ business realities.
About the firm →
